Question 1: Percents
Medium · Percents
Every employee of a company works in exactly one of its two divisions, Sales and Operations. From last year to this year, the Sales division's payroll rose by 8 percent and the Operations division's payroll rose by 3 percent. Did the company's total payroll rise by more than 5 percent?
- (1)Last year the Sales division had more employees than the Operations division had.
- (2)Last year the Sales division's payroll was larger than the Operations division's payroll.
- A. Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient.
- B. Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient.
- C. BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is sufficient.
- D. EACH statement ALONE is sufficient.
- E. Statements (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient.
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: B. Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient.
- A. More employees in Sales says nothing about its share of payroll: 10 Sales employees paid $300,000 against 6 in Operations paid $700,000 gives a rise of only 4.5 percent.
- B. Correct. A Sales share above one half makes the rise more than 0.5 × 8 + 0.5 × 3 = 5.5 percent, so the answer is yes.
- C. Statement (2) settles the question without statement (1), which says nothing about how the payroll is split.
- D. Statement (1) is not sufficient: headcounts do not fix the payroll weights, and the rise can fall on either side of 5 percent.
- E. Statement (2) alone answers the question, so the pair is certainly sufficient.
How to solve it
The company's percent rise is a weighted average of 8 and 3, weighted by each division's share of last year's payroll. If Sales held a share w, the company's payroll rose by 8w + 3(1 − w) = 3 + 5w percent, which is more than 5 exactly when w is more than 0.4. Statement (1) compares headcounts, not payrolls. If the 10 Sales employees were paid $300,000 in total and the 6 Operations employees $700,000, w = 0.3 and the rise is 4.5 percent; if Sales was paid $600,000 and Operations $400,000, the rise is 6 percent. So statement (1) is not sufficient. Statement (2) says w is more than 0.5, so the rise is more than 5.5 percent and the answer is yes. The answer is B.
Why it is medium difficulty: The trap statement compares headcounts, which look like the weights of the average; the weights are in fact each division's share of payroll.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.