Question 1: Inequalities
Medium · Inequalities
If x, y and z are real numbers such that x + y + z = 9 and x² + y² + z² = 33, what is the greatest possible value of z?
- A. 5
- B. 3 + √6
- C. √33
- D. 6
- E. 9
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A. 5
- A. Correct. The conditions force (z − 1)(z − 5) ≤ 0, and z = 5 is reached with x = y = 2.
- B. Since 33 = 27 + 6, the squared distances of the three numbers from their mean of 3 add to 6. Giving all of that to z makes z − 3 = √6, but then x and y would both equal 3 and the sum would exceed 9. When z rises, x and y must fall, and their distances from 3 use up part of the 6.
- C. This uses only the sum of the squares, with x = y = 0, and ignores the condition that the three numbers add to 9.
- D. If z is d above the mean of 3, then x and y are each d/2 below it, so the squared distances add to d² + d²/2 = (3/2)d² = 6 and d = 2. Solving d² = 6 × (3/2) = 9 instead inverts that factor and gives d = 3.
- E. This uses only the sum, with x = y = 0, and ignores the sum of the squares: 9² alone is already 81.
How to solve it
For a given z, x + y = 9 − z and x² + y² = 33 − z². Two numbers with a fixed sum have the smallest sum of squares when they are equal, so x² + y² is at least (x + y)²/2. Real x and y therefore exist only if 33 − z² ≥ (9 − z)²/2. Doubling gives 66 − 2z² ≥ 81 − 18z + z², so 3z² − 18z + 15 ≤ 0, or (z − 1)(z − 5) ≤ 0. So z lies between 1 and 5. z = 5 is possible, with x = y = 2: 2 + 2 + 5 = 9 and 4 + 4 + 25 = 33.
Why it is medium difficulty: Two symmetric conditions have to be turned into a bound on one variable, which needs the fact that two numbers with a fixed sum have the smallest sum of squares when they are equal; the natural variance-style shortcut lets z take all of the spread and overshoots.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.