Question 1: Percents
Medium · Percents
In a town, 60 percent of adults own a car, 45 percent own a bicycle and 30 percent own a motorcycle. What is the least possible percent of adults who own at least two of these three kinds of vehicle?
- A. 0%
- B. 5%
- C. 11 2/3%
- D. 17.5%
- E. 35%
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: D. 17.5%
- A. 0% assumes the three groups can be kept separate, but 60 + 45 + 30 = 135 is more than 100, so some adults must own more than one kind.
- B. 5% is the least overlap between car owners and bicycle owners alone: 60 + 45 − 100. It leaves out the 30 percent who own motorcycles.
- C. This divides the 35-point overshoot by 3, as if an owner of all three kinds accounted for 3 points of it. That adult is counted 3 times but is one person, so the overshoot is only 2 points.
- D. Correct. The 35-point overshoot is covered most economically by owners of all three kinds, 2 points each, and a town with 17.5 percent such owners is possible.
- E. 35% assumes every adult counted more than once owns exactly two kinds. Owners of all three kinds absorb 2 points each, which halves the number of adults needed.
How to solve it
The three percents add to 135, which is 35 more than 100. Count each adult once for every kind of vehicle owned: an adult with exactly two kinds is counted one extra time, an adult with all three is counted two extra times, and an adult with none is counted one time too few. So if t percent own exactly two kinds and u percent own all three, t + 2u is at least 35. The percent owning at least two kinds is t + u, which is smallest when all of the overlap comes from owners of all three: u = 17.5 and t = 0. That is possible: 17.5 percent own all three, and 42.5, 27.5 and 12.5 percent own only a car, only a bicycle and only a motorcycle, which accounts for all 100 percent of adults.
Why it is medium difficulty: Solvers who know the three-group formula rarely know how to minimize with it: the 35 points by which the percents overshoot 100 have to be converted into people, with an owner of all three kinds absorbing two points, and the result then has to be checked for feasibility; the usual exactly-two reading gives 35 percent.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.