Question 1: Argument Evaluation
Medium · Argument Evaluation
Two years ago the town of Fernhill installed speed cameras at the twelve intersections that had recorded the most traffic collisions in the year before. In the year after the cameras went in, collisions at those twelve intersections fell by 40 percent, while collisions at the town's other intersections fell by only 3 percent. Fernhill's traffic office concluded that the cameras caused most of the drop at the twelve intersections, and it has asked for funds to put cameras at thirty more.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the traffic office's conclusion?
- A. The cameras cost Fernhill less to operate than police patrols at the same intersections would cost.
- B. Since the cameras went in, some drivers who used to pass through the twelve intersections have begun taking longer routes on residential side streets to avoid them.
- C. At most of the twelve intersections, collisions in the year before the cameras went in were far above their usual yearly level.
- D. The traffic office also plans to lower the speed limit on the two main roads through the center of Fernhill.
- E. Most of the collisions at the twelve intersections in the year before the cameras went in involved a driver who was speeding.
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: C. At most of the twelve intersections, collisions in the year before the cameras went in were far above their usual yearly level.
- A. Cost bears on whether cameras are worth buying, not on whether they caused the fall in collisions.
- B. Drivers steering around the cameras is still an effect of the cameras, so the conclusion about the twelve intersections stands. This bears on the plan's net benefit instead.
- C. Correct. Sites picked for an unusually bad year would tend to see fewer collisions the next year anyway, so much of the 40 percent fall need not be due to the cameras.
- D. A change that has not yet been made cannot explain a fall in collisions that has already happened.
- E. If speeding caused most of those collisions, cameras that deter speeding are a likely cause of the fall, so this supports the office.
How to solve it
The twelve intersections were chosen because they had just had their worst year. A count that is unusually high one year tends to fall back toward its normal level the next, whether or not anything is done, so a sharp drop at sites picked for an extreme year is expected anyway, and the other intersections, which were not picked for a bad year, are no fair comparison. If most of the twelve had an abnormally bad year before the cameras, much of the 40 percent fall is a return to normal rather than an effect of the cameras.
Why it is medium difficulty: The key attacks how the intersections were chosen rather than naming a rival event, so the fall has to be recognized as a likely return to normal.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.