Question 1: Inference
Medium · Inference
Riders on the Lakeshore commuter line pay with either single tickets or monthly passes; the line sells no other fares. At the start of last year the price of a monthly pass rose by 15 percent and the price of a single ticket stayed the same; neither price changed at any other time last year or the year before. Compared with the year before, the number of monthly passes sold last year fell by 5 percent, and revenue from single tickets rose.
Which of the following can most properly be inferred from the statements above?
- A. The line earned less from monthly passes last year than it had the year before.
- B. More people rode the Lakeshore line last year than the year before, although fewer monthly passes were sold.
- C. Some riders who had bought monthly passes the year before switched to single tickets last year because passes had become more expensive.
- D. Had the price of a monthly pass stayed the same, at least as many passes would have been sold last year as the year before.
- E. The line's total revenue from fares was higher last year than it had been the year before.
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: E. The line's total revenue from fares was higher last year than it had been the year before.
- A. Fewer passes were sold, but each cost 15 percent more, so pass revenue rose by about 9 percent, since 1.15 × 0.95 = 1.0925.
- B. More single tickets were sold and fewer passes, and the statements give no count of riders, so whether more people rode cannot be told.
- C. The statements report what happened to sales, not why. The extra single-ticket revenue could have come entirely from new riders.
- D. Nothing says what pass sales would have been at the old price; they might have fallen anyway.
- E. Correct. Pass revenue was 1.15 × 0.95 = 1.0925 times its earlier level and single-ticket revenue also rose, so the total must have risen.
How to solve it
Revenue from passes is the price of a pass times the number sold. Last year the price was 1.15 times its old level and sales were 0.95 times, so pass revenue was 1.15 × 0.95 = 1.0925 times the year before, up by about 9 percent. Revenue from single tickets rose as well, and the line sells no other kind of fare, so its total fare revenue must have risen. The statements say nothing about why riders bought what they did, or about how many people rode.
Why it is medium difficulty: The key needs one multiplication, 1.15 × 0.95, to see that pass revenue rose despite falling sales; a candidate who skips it is drawn to the opposite claim.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.