Question 1: Evaluation of a Plan
Medium · Evaluation of a Plan
Seabirds that dive for bait while a longline is being set, before the hooks sink out of reach, are often hooked and drowned. To reduce the number of seabirds its boats kill, the Port Ardell fishing fleet plans to set all its lines after dark. The fleet's managers note that the albatrosses that follow its boats feed almost entirely by day, so they will not be diving for bait while the lines go out.
Which of the following, if true, most strongly suggests that the plan will not achieve its goal?
- A. Most of the birds killed on the fleet's lines in recent years were petrels of a kind that feeds mainly at night.
- B. Lines set after dark in a trial last season caught about as many fish as lines set in daylight.
- C. Albatrosses rarely follow fishing boats after dark, even boats that carry bright deck lights.
- D. Some fleets elsewhere have cut seabird deaths by weighting their lines so that the baited hooks sink faster.
- E. Albatross numbers in the region have been falling for several decades, and a breeding pair raises at most one chick every other year.
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A. Most of the birds killed on the fleet's lines in recent years were petrels of a kind that feeds mainly at night.
- A. Correct. The plan protects day-feeding albatrosses, but if most victims are night-feeding petrels, setting lines after dark puts the bait in front of the birds most at risk.
- B. The size of the catch matters to whether the fleet will accept the plan, not to whether the plan reduces seabird deaths.
- C. Albatrosses that stayed with the boats at night could still dive for bait, so this closes a gap in the plan and supports it.
- D. Another method working elsewhere does not show that this one will fail.
- E. Falling numbers make the goal more urgent but say nothing about whether setting lines after dark will reach it.
How to solve it
The plan is built around albatrosses, but its goal is fewer seabird deaths of every kind. If most of the birds the fleet kills are petrels that feed at night, moving the setting of lines into darkness moves it into the hours when the main victims are feeding. Deaths may then not fall at all, and could rise.
Why it is medium difficulty: The managers' reasoning about albatrosses is sound, so the key works only once the candidate sees that the goal covers every seabird, not the one kind the plan was built around.
Written for this page. It does not appear in any timed paper.